Precise claim — English definition
A specific, arguable thesis that stakes out a limited, defensible position rather than a vague topic.
Where it is taught
- Constructing Arguments — Public Argument, Rhetoric & Competing Accounts, English 11: American Voices, Identity & Public Memory, Grade 11
In use
Analyzing arguments and building them draw on the same parts — but constructing one means you are now responsible for every joint, and it begins with a precise claim.
Constructing Arguments
Questions using precise claim
Problem 1
Which is the strongest, most precise claim for an argument?
- Homework is a topic worth discussing.
- There are many opinions about homework.
- High schools should cap graded homework at one hour per night, because beyond that point additional homework shows little effect on learning while measurably harming sleep.
- Homework has existed for a long time.
Answer and explanation
High schools should cap graded homework at one hour per night, because beyond that point additional homework shows little effect on learning while measurably harming sleep.
Only this option is arguable, limited, and significant — it takes a specific side and previews its reasoning.